Goats Milk Yogurt Recipe I must confess that I am not an authority on homemade goat’s milk yogurt making. On the other hand, I make the best goat’s milk yogurt!   You will love this goat's milk yogurt recipe. I turned to the Internet for my yogurt making education. Although I learned a lot, the goat’s milk yogurt did not come out very well. I used the crockpot method and that was just watery with no body to it. A warm cooler box. I tried in the oven and endeavoring to keep a constant temperature. That resulted in slimy, stringy yogurt, from that I turned it into goat’s milk yogurt ice cream so that it was not wasted. I used different brands of plain organic goat’s milk yogurts as starters. Then I perfected it, I think it is a combination of a good starter and a good method. Updated Notes from when I first made this in 2016 - I have learned that goat's milk yogurt does not thicken as much as cow's milk yogurt. In the above photo and others on this page